轴向磁通与径向磁通反凸极永磁同步电机性能对比研究

Performance comparison between axial and radial flux reverse-salient permanent magnet motors

  • 摘要: 反凸极永磁同步电机(reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motor, RS-PMSM)的直轴电感大于交轴电感,具有恒功率调速范围宽、过载能力强和永磁体不易退磁等优势,适用于电驱系统等调速范围要求高的场合。由于主磁场方向不同,导致径向磁通和轴向磁通反凸极永磁同步电机在结构形式及电磁性能上存在显著差异。首先,提出径向磁通和轴向磁通两种反凸极永磁同步电机拓扑结构,分别建立对应交直轴等效磁路,分析磁场调节机理;其次,基于有限元法对比研究两种电机的转矩密度、转矩波动、恒功率调速范围和效率等电磁性能。结果表明,径向磁通反凸极永磁同步电机在转矩波动及恒功率调速范围方面性能更优,而轴向磁通反凸极永磁同步电机在转矩密度及效率方面具有一定优势。最后,研制一台径向磁通反凸极永磁同步电机样机,通过实验验证有限元分析结果的准确性。通过对两种电机的性能研究,明确了不同类型反凸极永磁同步电机的电磁特性差异及适用场景,为其工程应用提供理论依据。

     

    Abstract: A reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motor has a direct-axis inductance larger than quadrature-axis inductance, and possesses the advantages of wide constant-power speed range, strong overload capability and low demagnetization risk of permanent magnets, which is suitable for electric drive systems and other occasions with high speed regulation requirements. Due to the different directions of the main magnetic field, radial-flux and axial-flux reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motors show significant differences in topological structures and electromagnetic performances. Firstly, two topological structures of reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motors are proposed, namely radial flux and axial flux. Corresponding equivalent magnetic circuits in the AC and DC axes are established respectively, and the magnetic field regulation mechanism is analyzed. Secondly, the electromagnetic performances of the two motors, such as torque density, torque ripple, constant-power speed range and efficiency, are compared and studied based on the finite element method. The results show that the radial-flux reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motor performs better in torque ripple and constant-power speed range, while the axial-flux reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motor has certain advantages in torque density and efficiency. Finally, a prototype of radial-flux reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motor is developed, and the accuracy of the finite element analysis results is verified by experiments. The performance research on the two motors clarifies the differences in electromagnetic characteristics and applicable scenarios of different types of reverse-salient permanent magnet synchronous motors, which provides a theoretical basis for their engineering applications.

     

/

返回文章
返回